Product reviews for Why haven't they passed yet?

Danny Metters, Principal and CEO, Bishop Burton College and Riseholme College

Why Haven’t They Passed Yet? offers a powerful and much-needed reframing of literacy within FE, particularly for learners undertaking GCSE English resits. Rather than presenting literacy as a mechanistic pathway to exam success, the authors collectively position it as a transformative, social and deeply human endeavour – one that is intrinsically linked to issues of equity, identity and social mobility.

What stands out most powerfully is its rejection of deficit thinking. Too often, learners who have not yet achieved a grade 4 in English are defined by what they cannot do, rather than recognised for the knowledge, experiences and potential they bring. This collection challenges that narrative convincingly. It reminds us that prior non-achievement is rarely a reflection of ability alone; it is shaped by context, confidence, curriculum and, at times, the limitations of our own approaches as a system. Applying English to a subject-specialist interest and a focus on developing key skills is impactful for the individual and the development of industry-related knowledge.

Each chapter reimagines literacy as a cornerstone of social mobility. They position it not as a narrow set of exam skills, but as a gateway to participation – enabling learners to articulate their views, engage critically with information and take their place confidently in society and the workplace. In doing so, they align strongly with the broader mission of FE: to transform lives, not just deliver qualifications.

What I find particularly compelling is the emphasis on pedagogy. The focus on dialogic practice, learner voice, identity and the importance of time to think challenges us as leaders to reflect on the environments we create for both staff and students. If we are serious about improving literacy outcomes, we must also be serious about creating the conditions in which thinking, confidence and independence can flourish.

This is not a book about lowering expectations; it is about raising them in the right way. It asks us to move beyond teaching to the test and instead equip learners with the skills they need in order to navigate an increasingly complex world.

For leaders, practitioners and policy-makers alike, Why Haven’t They Passed Yet? is both a challenge and a call to action.

Bethan | 15/11/2026 14:25
Was this review helpful? Yes No (0/0)